@PravinJ@RahulDeshpande
i want to know the dhan whatever will be pledged and need to know the haircut ,
can you share the file then its will be very usefull for us
then i need to transfer securities from zerodha to dhan , can you please help in this matter , nd whatever the charges include
Hi riyas, i did some recently, you will get to know only when u are about to Pledge in case of stocks, as it varies . there is no excel file as of now , me too waiting
We have this built-in internally in the product flow. Can you share lis of securities you are looking for this information for, we will share the applicability and haircut. We are on feedback@dhan.co
Last time I had similar ask. Finally, I had to go to Customer Support, Finance and then a telephonic call to get this done.
At the end, I also provided feedback to have a community post on this subject with URL of public XLS listing all important notes clearly with example. But, today finding another person in the community asking for same information.
In summary, no steps taken on feedback and turnaround time remains same for the end customer.
Yes, we have made a note on this and will introduce something on this lines. We like to build flows that are deeply integrated in product experience, which is what Dhan experience is all about.
@amit yesterday i also tried to pledge every securities 20% above , see in zerodha i am holding 1 cr rupees the same i pledge the haircut in zerodha maximum 12% only in ETF and mutual fund ; all bluechip stock are 8 to 12% only
in DHAN i buy some shares its haircut minimum 20% , i will not here in DHAN anymore , this is fraud by dhan, NSE is giving colleterial , DHAN is not giving , then why dhan is taking more haircut , these people keeping some money for prop trading i think - irrespective DHAN , i already post in Zerodha community , no one will not come in dhan
Zerodha success is only a honest with client - Dhan will never come to near zerodha -
there is nothing different between zerodha and dhan every body 20 ruopees
We launched pledge just few days back… will update this risk policy accordingly We take feedback from users and build experience on Dhan based on that.
We operate super transparently here. No post on Dhan community, no matter how negative or critic is ever deleted from here.
You will see a new update on this soon. Its just 5 month that Dhan is live for users, and we are building a better experience much faster than anyone.
@PravinJ let see your words as honest - i will not sell my holding in dhan whatever i purchase , if you bring pledging haircut like zerodha minimal haircut - then i will rethink dhan is my trading terminal
@amit Liquidbees ETF is worst etf , in DHAN is ok , because there is no mutual fund pledging in dhan , in liquidbees evey month they will deduct tax from primary NAV after every thing (-) 2.5% hardly we can get
in Zerodha moneymarket fund i pledged for cash component - its giving 5 % this year its will compond there itself we dont want to repledge again and again in the case of liquid bees
Additionally, Dhan possibly is only stock trading platform in country that allows Pledge Margin benefit that you get - to be utilised for trading against all segments and exchanges - this includes Option Buying / Selling, Futures, Cash, Commodities, Currencies and across all exchanges. Many of the best brokers in country, will not extend this.
Additionally, Pledged stocks are visible in portfolio and unpledge is inline while selling. No need to unpledge and them sell.
Debt MF like Liquid or MMF pledging is a must for proper margin management.
Just choose Direct - Growth and leave it there.
Actual Cash should be priority only for MTM.